In an individual chapter 11 case, 530 Mashta, LLC and Tri-Cap Holdings, LLC moved to dismiss the case for cause under 11 U.S.C. § 1112(b)(1). The Debtor filed the case after the Judgment Creditors obtained final judgments exceeding $17 million and began collection activity. The Debtor’s proposed plan depended on three primary sources of value: consulting income from Black Dove, Inc., potential recovery in the BAA / BA Tech Litigation, and monetization of alleged equity in the 115 Blue Spruce Lane property (the "BSL Property").
The Court granted the motion to dismiss, finding cause under § 1112(b). Applying the totality of the circumstances and the bad-faith factors used in chapter 11 cases, the Court found that the case was filed and prosecuted in bad faith. Although the case did not present itself as a classic single-asset real estate case, the Court found that, when the layers were peeled back, the case was effectively about the Debtor’s effort to remain in and monetize the BSL Property. The Court found the Debtor’s proposed funding sources were contingent, disputed, and speculative.
The Court found that the case was effectively a two-party dispute between the Debtor and the Judgment Creditors. The Judgment Creditors held the dominant liquidated claims. The Court discounted the $119 million claim filed by the Estate of ngena, GmbH, which had not been scheduled by the Debtor and was filed only after the Debtor traveled to Germany and met with the insolvency administrator. The Court viewed that claim as a “friendly” claim used to make the case appear less like a two-party dispute and to create a potential impaired accepting class.
The Court also found that the Debtor had no operating business, no employees, no trade creditors, and no revenue-generating enterprise capable of rehabilitation. His plan depended primarily on litigation outcomes rather than business operations. The filing occurred after entry of the Florida judgments and during active collection activity, and the Court found that the Debtor had attempted to use bankruptcy as a forum-shopping and delay mechanism, including in connection with the Pitkin County litigation concerning the BSL Property.
The Court rejected the Debtor’s proposed funding sources as insufficient to support a confirmable plan. The Black Dove consulting arrangement produced limited and inconsistent income, was terminable on 30 days’ notice, and did not provide a reliable basis for plan funding. The Debtor’s expectation of increased compensation or equity from Black Dove was speculative. The Court also discounted testimony from Black Dove’s CEO because of his friendship with the Debtor, Black Dove’s failure to pay all amounts due under the consulting agreement, uncertainty over future funding, and the witness’s failure to comply with a subpoena.
The Court found that the BSL Property did not provide a reliable source of value. The Special Master in the Pitkin County litigation had ruled against the Debtor, determined that Dinamo owned the membership interests in 115 Blue Spruce Lane, LLC, rejected the Debtor’s constructive trust and fraudulent transfer theories, and concluded that the governing agreements created an equitable mortgage requiring judicial foreclosure. Although the Debtor objected to that ruling, the Court found that any realization of value from the property remained disputed, delayed, and uncertain.
The Court also found the BAA / BA Tech Litigation too speculative to support a plan. The Debtor did not present credible evidence explaining the claims, the likelihood of success, or collectability. Any recovery would also be reduced by a 40% contingency fee and subject to the Judgment Creditors’ charging order before any value could benefit the bankruptcy estate.
The Court separately found cause under § 1112(b)(4)(A) for continuing loss or diminution of the estate and the absence of a reasonable likelihood of rehabilitation. Monthly operating reports showed expenses exceeded income, and those figures did not include substantial unpaid post-petition carrying costs associated with the Debtor’s continued occupancy of the BSL Property, attorney’s fees, special master fees, or special counsel fees. The Court also noted disclosure problems, including omitted art-sale proceeds, an unscheduled Venmo account, unexplained redactions in the contingency fee agreement, inaccurate plan statements, and a possible tax liability that had not been addressed in the Debtor’s projections.
The Court held that the exception under § 1112(b)(2) did not apply. The Debtor’s compliance with basic chapter 11 requirements, including filing reports, attending meetings, producing documents, maintaining insurance, and filing a plan, did not constitute unusual circumstances. The Debtor also failed to show a reasonable likelihood of confirming a plan within a reasonable time or curing the grounds for dismissal.
The Court determined that dismissal, rather than conversion to chapter 7, was in the best interests of creditors and the estate. The Debtor admitted there would be no distribution in chapter 7, and the estate lacked cash or readily administered non-contingent assets. A chapter 7 trustee would inherit expensive, uncertain litigation in multiple forums without a clear net benefit to creditors. Dismissal would allow the parties to proceed in the non-bankruptcy forums where their disputes were already pending.
Although the Court found bad faith and dismissed the case, it declined to impose a refiling bar. The Court recognized the risk of future abuse but found no record of multiple successive filings by the Debtor, no violation of prior bar orders, and no showing that the Debtor was poised to refile immediately. The Court concluded that dismissal was sufficient to address the present misuse of chapter 11, while any future filing would be subject to scrutiny based on the record developed in the case.