In a Chapter 13 case, Creditors objected to plan confirmation, primarily alleging lack of good faith and lack of feasibility. Prior to the bankruptcy case, Creditors obtained a state court judgment for money damages against Debtors, after which Creditors propounded extensive post-judgment discovery. During the bankruptcy case, Creditors also propounded extensive, contentious discovery. Relief from stay was granted to allow the appeal of the state court judgment to proceed. The appellate court affirmed the trial court and remanded the case to determine if treble damages were appropriate (an issue that was not resolved at the time of confirmation). Debtors admitted that their debt from the state court judgment is non-dischargeable.
The Court confirmed the Chapter 13 plan. The Court found that the plan was feasible based on the amount of the proposed payments and the stability of Debtors’ income. The Court also found that the plan and the bankruptcy case were filed in good faith. Although Debtors made mistakes in completing bankruptcy forms and answering interrogatories, they were accidental, honest mistakes and Debtors amended their bankruptcy schedules twice. Similarly, although Debtors closed on the purchase of a home after the state court judgment entered against them, their mortgage payments did not differ significantly from their previous rental housing payments and they cancelled life insurance payments to provide more return to creditors. Debtors also committed substantial income to pay creditors under the plan. Even though the Chapter 13 Trustee had objected to confirmation, those objections were consensually resolved.