The Debtors filed for bankruptcy protection under Chapter 7. Their case started out uneventfully. However, after the Debtors received their discharge, the Chapter 7 Trustee moved to employ a broker to sell the Debtors’ residence. The Trustee contended that there was sufficient equity in the house to pay the mortgage, closing costs and the Debtors’ homestead exemption as well as to pay some dividend to the unsecured creditors in the case. In response, the Debtors moved to convert their case to Chapter 13 to save their home.
The Chapter 7 Trustee objected that the Debtors were not eligible for Chapter 13 relief and that their case would be dismissed promptly upon conversion because the Debtors requested conversion in bad faith. The Trustee relied on Marrama v. Citizens Bank of Mass., 549 U.S. 365 (2007).
After considering the facts and law, the Court held that the Debtors were eligible for Chapter 13 relief based upon their financial circumstances at the time of conversion; and that they had not engaged in bad faith in their effort to convert to Chapter 13. The Court analyzed the facts using a totality of the circumstances test and the seven factors endorsed by the Tenth Circuit in In re Gier, 986 F.2d 1326, 1329 (10th Cir. 1993). When analyzing one of the Gier factors, the Debtors’ motivation for converting to Chapter 13, the Court found that the Debtors’ sole motivation was to save their home and such was a permissible motivation contemplated by Congress in enacting the provisions of Chapter 13. The Court granted the Debtors’ motion to convert to Chapter 13.