In the year prior to its bankruptcy, a corporate debtor made payments on a promissory note owed to an IRA. The debtor’s principal owned the IRA. The corporate debtor’s chapter 7 trustee sued the IRA and its custodian to recover the note payments as preferences. However, the IRA filed a motion to dismiss on the basis that the IRA was not the proper party because it is not a separate legal entity, claiming the Trustee should have sued the owner of the IRA. It also argued that, in this case, it would be futile for the Trustee to substitute the owner of the IRA as the defendant because the owner had filed his own individual bankruptcy and received a discharge, barring any pre-bankruptcy claims against him.
The Court first concluded that the IRA was not a separate legal entity. Instead it was an asset of the IRA Owner. The Court also rejected the Trustee’s argument that the IRA was a trust. As to the issue of whether the Trustee’s claims were barred by the owner’s discharge, the Trustee argued that his discharge did not encompass these preference claims because they were “in rem” claims. The Court analyzed decisions on the distinction between “in rem” and “in personam” issued by the Supreme Court and lower courts from other contexts, including cases on sovereign immunity and the constitutional limits of the bankruptcy courts’ jurisdiction. Lacking clear guidance from these cases, and absent a binding precedent to the contrary, the Court concluded that the recovery of preferentially transferred funds is an in personam claim. Accordingly, the Court dismissed the Trustee’s complaint.